{
  "schema": "synatrail-cookbook-agent-evidence-v1",
  "generatedAt": "2026-10-05T21:14:17.404Z",
  "execution": "real Synatrail dispatch/read/verification/compile/compute/result modules; deterministic provider protocol and source-response fixtures",
  "externalProviderCalls": 0,
  "officialWebRetrieval": {
    "file": "source-web-retrieval.txt",
    "tool": "web.run",
    "date": "2026-10-05",
    "extractedTextSha256": "73fa70a2f807eec9529d1417d38b0f720eb09dd19b3e84d40454eb7cc4e10dec"
  },
  "platformLiveSourceFetches": 0,
  "sourceReplayReads": 1,
  "goal": "Check whether the NASA GISS 2020 annual global anomaly reached at least 1.00 °C relative to the 1951–1980 baseline.",
  "humanQuestion": {
    "id": "my-question",
    "kind": "question",
    "title": "Did 2020 reach +1.00 °C?",
    "body": "Check whether the NASA GISS 2020 annual global anomaly reached at least 1.00 °C relative to the 1951–1980 baseline.",
    "origin": "human",
    "contentRevision": 1
  },
  "sourceLead": {
    "id": "nasa-earth-observatory-2020",
    "title": "NASA Earth Observatory: 2020 Tied for Warmest Year on Record",
    "url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/earth-observatory/2020-tied-for-warmest-year-on-record-147794/",
    "publisher": "NASA",
    "status": "search lead; unread"
  },
  "source": {
    "sourceId": "nasa-earth-observatory-2020",
    "sourceVersionId": "source-version:135cd968d22b1432",
    "url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/earth-observatory/2020-tied-for-warmest-year-on-record-147794/",
    "publisher": "NASA",
    "retrievedAt": "2026-10-05T21:14:17.354Z",
    "readMode": "bounded selected-excerpt replay; no live NASA network fetch by the Synatrail runner",
    "contentType": "text/plain",
    "originalFile": "source-response.txt",
    "originalSha256": "135cd968d22b1432b147e74e05365df00d562c278d83c80bdeb6bd116b147ac6",
    "originalBytes": 313,
    "independentWebRetrieval": {
      "file": "source-web-retrieval.txt",
      "tool": "web.run open",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-05",
      "pageLine": 268,
      "extractedTextSha256": "73fa70a2f807eec9529d1417d38b0f720eb09dd19b3e84d40454eb7cc4e10dec",
      "relation": "The replay quote is verified against this separately fetched official page extraction; this file is not raw HTTP response bytes."
    },
    "title": "science.nasa.gov",
    "coverage": {
      "characters": 309,
      "readCharacters": 309,
      "complete": true,
      "method": "bounded accessible response"
    },
    "passages": [
      {
        "id": "paragraph-1-0",
        "text": "NASA Earth Observatory — 2020 Tied for Warmest Year on Record (January 15, 2021)\nhttps://science.nasa.gov/earth/earth-observatory/2020-tied-for-warmest-year-on-record-147794/",
        "location": {
          "paragraph": 1,
          "start": 0,
          "end": 174
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "paragraph-2-0",
        "text": "the globally averaged temperature in 2020 was 1.02 degrees Celsius (1.84 degrees Fahrenheit) warmer than the baseline 1951–1980 mean\n",
        "location": {
          "paragraph": 2,
          "start": 176,
          "end": 309
        }
      }
    ]
  },
  "agentFinding": {
    "id": "agent-finding-2020",
    "kind": "insight",
    "title": "NASA reported +1.02 °C for 2020",
    "body": "NASA GISS reported 2020 at +1.02 °C against the 1951–1980 mean.",
    "origin": "agent",
    "evidenceStatus": "pending human review",
    "sourceVersionId": "source-version:135cd968d22b1432",
    "passageId": "paragraph-2-0",
    "assertionRevision": 1,
    "limits": [
      "A fresh full NASA data download and uncertainty interpretation."
    ]
  },
  "compiledTest": {
    "testId": "agent-test-2020-threshold",
    "planRevision": 1,
    "hypothesisNodeId": "agent-finding-2020",
    "hypothesisRevision": 1,
    "hypothesis": "The cited 2020 anomaly is at least 1.00 °C above the 1951–1980 mean.",
    "falsifying": "The cited value is below 1.00 °C.",
    "disproof": "A negative computed margin would disprove this narrow threshold claim.",
    "metric": {
      "name": "Margin above +1.00 °C",
      "units": "K"
    },
    "threshold": {
      "comparison": "gte",
      "value": 0
    },
    "sampleOrDuration": {
      "kind": "sample",
      "required": 1,
      "unit": "cited annual value"
    },
    "killRule": {
      "enabled": false,
      "reason": "One bounded desk computation creates no operational exposure."
    },
    "costCapUsd": 2,
    "method": "numerical",
    "numerical": {
      "tool": "sweep",
      "config": {
        "formula": "observed - target",
        "variables": [
          {
            "name": "observed",
            "unit": "K",
            "values": [
              1.02
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "target",
            "unit": "K",
            "values": [
              1
            ]
          }
        ],
        "outputUnit": "K"
      },
      "parameters": {
        "observed": {
          "type": "number",
          "unit": "K",
          "value": 1.02
        },
        "target": {
          "type": "number",
          "unit": "K",
          "value": 1
        }
      },
      "measurement": {
        "kind": "row",
        "match": {
          "column": "observed",
          "value": 1.02
        },
        "column": "output"
      }
    },
    "dataNeeds": [],
    "context": {
      "evidenceBasis": "source-version:135cd968d22b1432:paragraph-2-0",
      "assumptions": [
        "The selected NASA excerpt is a faithful replay."
      ],
      "limitations": [
        "This verifies one quoted numeric threshold only; it does not test climate causation, uncertainty, or a revised live data release."
      ],
      "sources": [
        "source-version:135cd968d22b1432:paragraph-2-0"
      ]
    }
  },
  "computation": {
    "outputVersionId": "experiment:agent-evidence:1:output",
    "output": {
      "kind": "sweep",
      "rows": [
        {
          "observed": 1.02,
          "target": 1,
          "output": 0.020000000000000018
        }
      ],
      "rowCount": 1,
      "columns": {
        "observed": {
          "type": "number",
          "unit": "K"
        },
        "target": {
          "type": "number",
          "unit": "K"
        },
        "output": {
          "type": "number",
          "unit": "K"
        }
      },
      "units": {
        "observed": "K",
        "target": "K",
        "output": "K"
      },
      "summary": {
        "scenarios": 1,
        "assumption": "A deterministic Cartesian sweep of the supplied assumptions."
      }
    },
    "receipts": [
      {
        "id": "result",
        "tool": "sweep",
        "inputRefs": [],
        "config": {
          "formula": "observed - target",
          "variables": [
            {
              "name": "observed",
              "unit": "K",
              "values": [
                1.02
              ]
            },
            {
              "name": "target",
              "unit": "K",
              "values": [
                1
              ]
            }
          ],
          "outputUnit": "K"
        },
        "methodVersion": "canvas/1",
        "inputFingerprint": "7cf84024cd7de67ad04d2584f694d0f5b54727e3ce35e2c2f63bea1c230c2a6a",
        "resultHash": "ee8a98191099316d685263ddccea40e16ec47fb82577076ebb85b520b3a1f482",
        "outputVersionId": "experiment:agent-evidence:1:result",
        "reusedFrom": null,
        "rowCount": 1,
        "elapsedMs": 2
      }
    ],
    "stepResults": {},
    "provenance": {
      "softwareVersion": "canvas-compute/1.0.0",
      "inputHashes": [],
      "parameters": {},
      "seeds": [],
      "reusedSteps": [],
      "elapsedMs": 2
    }
  },
  "measurement": {
    "value": 0.020000000000000018,
    "units": "K"
  },
  "sampleCount": 1,
  "platformResult": {
    "experimentIdAndRevision": {
      "id": "experiment:agent-evidence:1",
      "revision": 1
    },
    "candidateAssertionRevision": {
      "candidateId": "agent-finding-2020",
      "revision": 1
    },
    "laneId": "lane:agent-evidence:1",
    "metrics": {
      "Margin above +1.00 °C": {
        "value": 0.020000000000000018,
        "units": "K"
      }
    },
    "sample": {
      "kind": "sample",
      "achieved": 1,
      "required": 1,
      "unit": "cited annual value",
      "exclusions": []
    },
    "conditions": [
      "Selected NASA excerpt replay and exact cited passage"
    ],
    "actionReceipts": [
      "ee8a98191099316d685263ddccea40e16ec47fb82577076ebb85b520b3a1f482"
    ],
    "startedAt": "2026-10-05T21:14:17.403Z",
    "endedAt": "2026-10-05T21:14:17.403Z",
    "actualCost": 0,
    "registeredThreshold": {
      "metric": "Margin above +1.00 °C",
      "units": "K",
      "comparison": "gte",
      "value": 0
    },
    "observedVerdict": "met",
    "observedVerdictReason": "The measured value met the registered threshold.",
    "collector": {
      "kind": "computation",
      "actor": "Synatrail deterministic computation",
      "receiptRef": "ee8a98191099316d685263ddccea40e16ec47fb82577076ebb85b520b3a1f482"
    },
    "fixture": false,
    "kind": "original",
    "supersedes": null,
    "createdAt": "2026-10-05T21:14:17.404Z"
  },
  "verdict": "met",
  "pendingHumanDecision": {
    "action": "accept or challenge the Agent finding after inspecting the passage and replay boundary",
    "status": "not taken"
  },
  "dispatcherReceipts": [
    {
      "index": 1,
      "requestedTools": [
        "search_public",
        "read_source",
        "propose_finding",
        "request_concept_reframe",
        "run_computation",
        "finish_research"
      ],
      "selectedTool": "search_public",
      "promptSha256": "0e72055817283269a5a6242e7d0000a464c5352611d9418e44c6282f7c5b80f0",
      "authorityIssued": true,
      "fixture": "deterministic OpenAI Responses protocol; no external model call"
    },
    {
      "index": 2,
      "requestedTools": [
        "search_public",
        "read_source",
        "propose_finding",
        "request_concept_reframe",
        "run_computation",
        "finish_research"
      ],
      "selectedTool": "read_source",
      "promptSha256": "a5bb66186550375627a8a373890bf683400d7f05f89a22d01ec5900fb50ffbff",
      "authorityIssued": true,
      "fixture": "deterministic OpenAI Responses protocol; no external model call"
    },
    {
      "index": 3,
      "requestedTools": [
        "search_public",
        "read_source",
        "propose_finding",
        "request_concept_reframe",
        "run_computation",
        "finish_research"
      ],
      "selectedTool": "propose_finding",
      "promptSha256": "0b543028d8af74ca4f7fa069d6398de73370ec002af2e90b55784d7258c8fb2c",
      "authorityIssued": true,
      "fixture": "deterministic OpenAI Responses protocol; no external model call"
    },
    {
      "index": 4,
      "requestedTools": [
        "assess_evidence_passages"
      ],
      "selectedTool": "assess_evidence_passages",
      "promptSha256": "6aefbe0c6769b1e2e2218cc94882002c90e12cce7be3fbff492b4cdaa594dc9b",
      "authorityIssued": true,
      "fixture": "deterministic OpenAI Responses protocol; no external model call"
    },
    {
      "index": 5,
      "requestedTools": [
        "compile_test_plan"
      ],
      "selectedTool": "compile_test_plan",
      "promptSha256": "f933a4b4d17f9c3718ab86b166f71b1d88972bdb16d93f0ecdadd9a34992a483",
      "authorityIssued": true,
      "fixture": "deterministic OpenAI Responses protocol; no external model call"
    },
    {
      "index": 6,
      "requestedTools": [
        "search_public",
        "read_source",
        "propose_finding",
        "request_concept_reframe",
        "run_computation",
        "finish_research"
      ],
      "selectedTool": "finish_research",
      "promptSha256": "9052b5e70244f7ddb99f1504e54c70280f7e3f9c58de3c0ced2cce90ebc17bc6",
      "authorityIssued": true,
      "fixture": "deterministic OpenAI Responses protocol; no external model call"
    }
  ],
  "steps": [
    {
      "step": "search_public",
      "input": {
        "queryIndex": 0,
        "reason": "Find NASA primary evidence for the 2020 GISS anomaly."
      },
      "result": [
        {
          "id": "nasa-earth-observatory-2020",
          "title": "NASA Earth Observatory: 2020 Tied for Warmest Year on Record",
          "url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/earth-observatory/2020-tied-for-warmest-year-on-record-147794/",
          "publisher": "NASA",
          "status": "search lead; unread"
        }
      ],
      "note": "The deterministic search index exposes a NASA primary-source lead, not read evidence."
    },
    {
      "step": "read_source",
      "input": {
        "sourceId": "nasa-earth-observatory-2020",
        "reason": "Read the NASA statement and preserve its original response bytes."
      },
      "result": {
        "sourceVersionId": "source-version:135cd968d22b1432",
        "passageIds": [
          "paragraph-1-0",
          "paragraph-2-0"
        ],
        "contentHash": "135cd968d22b1432b147e74e05365df00d562c278d83c80bdeb6bd116b147ac6",
        "coverage": {
          "characters": 309,
          "readCharacters": 309,
          "complete": true,
          "method": "bounded accessible response"
        }
      },
      "note": "Synatrail readCanvasURL executed the public URL policy, bounded response read and passage extraction against the retained replay bytes."
    },
    {
      "step": "propose_finding",
      "input": {
        "title": "NASA reported +1.02 °C for 2020",
        "claim": "NASA GISS reported 2020 at +1.02 °C against the 1951–1980 mean.",
        "targetUser": "A reader checking a published climate indicator",
        "mechanism": "A dated source statement provides one annual global anomaly value.",
        "intervention": "Pin the source version and run a threshold check.",
        "established": "The retained NASA excerpt states +1.02 °C.",
        "inferred": "The value exceeds +1.00 °C by 0.02 °C in this replay.",
        "assumptions": [
          "The selected excerpt faithfully reproduces the cited NASA statement."
        ],
        "alternatives": [
          "The live data table may carry a later revision or different rounding."
        ],
        "missingEvidence": [
          "A fresh full NASA data download and uncertainty interpretation."
        ],
        "nextTest": "Re-read NASA’s live full table and compare the 2020 annual entry.",
        "evidenceIds": [
          "source-version:135cd968d22b1432:paragraph-2-0"
        ],
        "fromNodeId": "my-question",
        "toNodeId": "",
        "relation": "informs",
        "rationale": "The source provides the value to check.",
        "targetEdgeId": "",
        "issueId": "",
        "assertionRevision": 1
      },
      "result": {
        "canvas": "agent",
        "nodeId": "agent-finding-2020",
        "status": "pending human review"
      },
      "note": "The finding remains on the Agent canvas. No My canvas acceptance is simulated."
    },
    {
      "step": "verify_evidence",
      "input": {
        "findings": [
          {
            "passageId": "paragraph-2-0",
            "quote": "the globally averaged temperature in 2020 was 1.02 degrees Celsius (1.84 degrees Fahrenheit) warmer than the baseline 1951–1980 mean",
            "reading": "supports",
            "why": "The quote explicitly gives 1.02 °C."
          },
          {
            "passageId": "paragraph-2-0",
            "quote": "NASA proved a 2 °C increase",
            "reading": "supports",
            "why": "Deliberately invalid fixture claim."
          }
        ]
      },
      "result": {
        "kept": [
          {
            "passageId": "paragraph-2-0",
            "quote": "the globally averaged temperature in 2020 was 1.02 degrees Celsius (1.84 degrees Fahrenheit) warmer than the baseline 1951–1980 mean",
            "reading": "supports",
            "why": "The quote explicitly gives 1.02 °C."
          }
        ],
        "dropped": [
          {
            "passageId": "paragraph-2-0",
            "reason": "not-verbatim"
          }
        ]
      },
      "note": "The production verifier retained the exact passage quote and rejected a made-up sentence."
    },
    {
      "step": "compile_test_plan",
      "input": {
        "tool": "compile_test_plan",
        "plan": {
          "testId": "agent-test-2020-threshold",
          "planRevision": 1,
          "hypothesisNodeId": "agent-finding-2020",
          "hypothesisRevision": 1,
          "hypothesis": "The cited 2020 anomaly is at least 1.00 °C above the 1951–1980 mean.",
          "falsifying": "The cited value is below 1.00 °C.",
          "metric": {
            "name": "Margin above +1.00 °C",
            "units": "K"
          },
          "threshold": {
            "comparison": "gte",
            "value": 0
          },
          "disproof": "A negative computed margin would disprove this narrow threshold claim.",
          "sampleOrDuration": {
            "kind": "sample",
            "required": 1,
            "unit": "cited annual value"
          },
          "killRule": {
            "enabled": false,
            "reason": "One bounded desk computation creates no operational exposure."
          },
          "costCapUsd": 2,
          "method": "numerical",
          "numerical": {
            "tool": "sweep",
            "config": {
              "formula": "observed - target",
              "variables": [
                {
                  "name": "observed",
                  "unit": "K",
                  "values": [
                    1.02
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "name": "target",
                  "unit": "K",
                  "values": [
                    1
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "outputUnit": "K"
            },
            "parameters": {
              "observed": {
                "type": "number",
                "unit": "K",
                "value": 1.02
              },
              "target": {
                "type": "number",
                "unit": "K",
                "value": 1
              }
            },
            "measurement": {
              "kind": "row",
              "match": {
                "column": "observed",
                "value": 1.02
              },
              "column": "output"
            }
          },
          "dataNeeds": [],
          "evidenceBasis": "source-version:135cd968d22b1432:paragraph-2-0",
          "assumptions": [
            "The selected NASA excerpt is a faithful replay."
          ],
          "limitations": [
            "This verifies one quoted numeric threshold only; it does not test climate causation, uncertainty, or a revised live data release."
          ],
          "sources": [
            "source-version:135cd968d22b1432:paragraph-2-0"
          ]
        }
      },
      "result": {
        "method": "numerical",
        "metric": {
          "name": "Margin above +1.00 °C",
          "units": "K"
        },
        "threshold": {
          "comparison": "gte",
          "value": 0
        },
        "computationTool": "sweep"
      },
      "note": "The production compiler validated units, bindings, measurement and executable tool configuration."
    },
    {
      "step": "run_computation",
      "input": {
        "experimentId": "experiment:agent-evidence:1",
        "sourceVersionId": "source-version:135cd968d22b1432",
        "testId": "agent-test-2020-threshold"
      },
      "result": {
        "measured": {
          "value": 0.020000000000000018,
          "units": "K"
        },
        "samples": 1,
        "verdict": "met",
        "outputVersionId": "experiment:agent-evidence:1:output",
        "computationReceipts": [
          {
            "id": "result",
            "tool": "sweep",
            "inputRefs": [],
            "config": {
              "formula": "observed - target",
              "variables": [
                {
                  "name": "observed",
                  "unit": "K",
                  "values": [
                    1.02
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "name": "target",
                  "unit": "K",
                  "values": [
                    1
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "outputUnit": "K"
            },
            "methodVersion": "canvas/1",
            "inputFingerprint": "7cf84024cd7de67ad04d2584f694d0f5b54727e3ce35e2c2f63bea1c230c2a6a",
            "resultHash": "ee8a98191099316d685263ddccea40e16ec47fb82577076ebb85b520b3a1f482",
            "outputVersionId": "experiment:agent-evidence:1:result",
            "reusedFrom": null,
            "rowCount": 1,
            "elapsedMs": 2
          }
        ],
        "platformResult": {
          "experimentIdAndRevision": {
            "id": "experiment:agent-evidence:1",
            "revision": 1
          },
          "candidateAssertionRevision": {
            "candidateId": "agent-finding-2020",
            "revision": 1
          },
          "laneId": "lane:agent-evidence:1",
          "metrics": {
            "Margin above +1.00 °C": {
              "value": 0.020000000000000018,
              "units": "K"
            }
          },
          "sample": {
            "kind": "sample",
            "achieved": 1,
            "required": 1,
            "unit": "cited annual value",
            "exclusions": []
          },
          "conditions": [
            "Selected NASA excerpt replay and exact cited passage"
          ],
          "actionReceipts": [
            "ee8a98191099316d685263ddccea40e16ec47fb82577076ebb85b520b3a1f482"
          ],
          "startedAt": "2026-10-05T21:14:17.403Z",
          "endedAt": "2026-10-05T21:14:17.403Z",
          "actualCost": 0,
          "registeredThreshold": {
            "metric": "Margin above +1.00 °C",
            "units": "K",
            "comparison": "gte",
            "value": 0
          },
          "observedVerdict": "met",
          "observedVerdictReason": "The measured value met the registered threshold.",
          "collector": {
            "kind": "computation",
            "actor": "Synatrail deterministic computation",
            "receiptRef": "ee8a98191099316d685263ddccea40e16ec47fb82577076ebb85b520b3a1f482"
          },
          "fixture": false,
          "kind": "original",
          "supersedes": null,
          "createdAt": "2026-10-05T21:14:17.404Z"
        }
      },
      "note": "Synatrail computed the sweep, extracted the pinned metric and sample, then cleanResult derived met from the registered threshold."
    },
    {
      "step": "finish_research",
      "input": {
        "reason": "The retained source quote and deterministic threshold check agree for this narrow claim.",
        "unresolved": [
          "The live full NASA release and uncertainty treatment were not checked in this offline replay."
        ]
      },
      "result": {
        "status": "completed with limitation"
      },
      "note": "The agent stopped with the unverified live-source question explicit."
    }
  ]
}
